Wait, what? I thought the whole purpose of the Hague Service Convention was to eliminate the need for diplomatic channels.
Well, not exactly. The primary purpose was to streamline and harmonize dozens (hundreds?) of disparate rulebooks to make it easier for documents to be served across borders. But a secondary aim was to make the involvement of consular officials unnecessary, thus speeding up service mechanisms considerably while still respecting states’ sovereign prerogatives in the procedure.
Today, when U.S. and Canadian lawyers send Hague Service Requests to foreign governments, we don’t need the State Department or Global Affairs Canada to be involved. We simply go directly to the appropriate Central Authority in the foreign country and that’s that. Sure, the various Central Authorities’ speed in getting the job done varies wildly, from a couple of weeks to a couple of years (yes, that says years— not a typo), but we don’t need embassy officials involved anywhere in the chain of custody, as it were. In jurisdictions that don’t object to Article 10 alternatives, even the Central Authority isn’t needed.
But on occasion, notably in cases governed by the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, it does become necessary to use diplomatic channels, whether for direct service of foreign states (28 U.S.C. §1608(a)) or Letter Rogatory service on agencies & instrumentalities (§1608(b)).
Recall that adherence to Hague strictures is mandatory (so sayeth O’Connor, J.), so it might seem that diplomatic means are off the table. Not so, thanks to Article 9 (text below), by which the Convention simply steps out of the way. Litigants are free to proceed.
Pretty straightforward stuff, though it’s very seldom even a question. (It’s necessary in Russia, I’m afraid.)
Article 9
Each Contracting State shall be free, in addition, to use consular channels to forward documents, for the purpose of service, to those authorities of another Contracting State which are designated by the latter for this purpose.
Each Contracting State may, if exceptional circumstances so require, use diplomatic channels for the same purpose.










